update sharing faq for 2023

docs/source/conf.py

@@ -201,6 +201,7 @@ intersphinx_mapping = {
     "python": ("https://docs.python.org/3/", None),
     "tornado": ("https://www.tornadoweb.org/en/stable/", None),
     "jupyter-server": ("https://jupyter-server.readthedocs.io/en/stable/", None),
+    "nbgitpuller": ("https://nbgitpuller.readthedocs.io/en/latest", None),
 }
 
 # -- Options for the opengraph extension -------------------------------------

docs/source/faq/faq.md

@@ -2,35 +2,75 @@
 
 ## How do I share links to notebooks?
 
-In short, where you see `/user/name/notebooks/foo.ipynb` use `/hub/user-redirect/notebooks/foo.ipynb` (replace `/user/name` with `/hub/user-redirect`).
-
 Sharing links to notebooks is a common activity,
-and can look different based on what you mean.
+and can look different depending on what you mean by 'share.'
 Your first instinct might be to copy the URL you see in the browser,
-e.g. `hub.jupyter.org/user/yourname/notebooks/coolthing.ipynb`.
+e.g. `jupyterhub.example/user/yourname/notebooks/coolthing.ipynb`,
-However, let's break down what this URL means:
+but this usually won't work, depending on the permissions of the person you share the link with.
 
-`hub.jupyter.org/user/yourname/` is the URL prefix handled by _your server_,
+Unfortunately, 'share' means at least a few things to people in a JupyterHub context.
-which means that sharing this URL is asking the person you share the link with
+We'll cover 3 common cases here, when they are applicable, and what assumptions they make:
-to come to _your server_ and look at the exact same file.
-In most circumstances, this is forbidden by permissions because the person you share with does not have access to your server.
-What actually happens when someone visits this URL will depend on whether your server is running and other factors.
 
-**But what is our actual goal?**
+1. sharing links that will open the same file on the visitor's own server
+2. sharing links that will bring the visitor to _your_ server (e.g. for real-time collaboration, or RTC)
+3. publishing notebooks and sharing links that will download the notebook into the user's server
 
-A typical situation is that you have some shared or common filesystem,
+### link to the same file on the visitor's server
-such that the same path corresponds to the same document
-(either the exact same document or another copy of it).
-Typically, what folks want when they do sharing like this
-is for each visitor to open the same file _on their own server_,
-so Breq would open `/user/breq/notebooks/foo.ipynb` and
-Seivarden would open `/user/seivarden/notebooks/foo.ipynb`, etc.
 
-JupyterHub has a special URL that does exactly this!
+This is for the case where you have JupyterHub on a shared (or sufficiently similar) filesystem, where you want to share a link that will cause users to login and start their _own_ server, to view or edit the file.
-It's called `/hub/user-redirect/...`.
-So if you replace `/user/yourname` in your URL bar
-with `/hub/user-redirect` any visitor should get the same
-URL on their own server, rather than visiting yours.
 
-In JupyterLab 2.0, this should also be the result of the "Copy Shareable Link"
+**Assumption:** the same path on someone else's server is valid and points to the same file
-action in the file browser.
+
+This is useful in e.g. classes where you know students have certain files in certain locations, or collaborations where you know you have a shared filesystem where everyone has access to the same files.
+
+A link should look like `https://jupyterhub.example/hub/user-redirect/lab/tree/foo.ipynb`.
+You can hand-craft these URLs from the URL you are looking at, where you see `/user/name/lab/tree/foo.ipynb` use `/hub/user-redirect/lab/tree/foo.ipynb` (replace `/user/name/` with `/hub/user-redirect/`).
+Or you can use JupyterLab's "copy shareable link" in the context menu in the file browser:
+
+![copy shareable link in JupyterLab](../images/shareable_link.webp)
+
+which will produce a correct URL with `/hub/user-redirect/` in it.
+
+### link to the file on your server
+
+This is for the case where you want to both be using _your_ server, e.g. for real-time collaboration (RTC).
+
+**Assumption:** the user has (or should have) access to your server.
+
+**Assumption:** your server is running _or_ the user has permission to start it.
+
+By default, JupyterHub users don't have access to each other's servers, but JupyterHub 2.0 administrators can grant users limited access permissions to each other's servers.
+If the visitor doesn't have access to the server, these links will result in a 403 Permission Denied error.
+
+In many cases, for this situation you can copy the link in your URL bar (`/user/yourname/lab`), or you can add `/tree/path/to/specific/notebook.ipynb` to open a specific file.
+
+The [jupyterlab-link-share] JupyterLab extension generates these links, and even can _grant_ other users access to your server.
+
+[jupyterlab-link-share]: https://github.com/jupyterlab-contrib/jupyterlab-link-share
+
+:::{warning}
+Note that the way the extension _grants_ access is handing over credentials to allow the other user to **_BECOME YOU_**.
+This is usually not appropriate in JupyterHub.
+:::
+
+### link to a published copy
+
+Another way to 'share' notebooks is to publish copies, e.g. pushing the notebook to a git repository and sharing a download link.
+This way is especially useful for course materials,
+where no assumptions are necessary about the user's environment,
+except for having one package installed.
+
+**Assumption:** The [nbgitpuller](inv:nbgitpuller#index) server extension is installed
+
+Unlike the other two methods, nbgitpuller doesn't provide an extension to copy a shareable link for the document you're currently looking at,
+but it does provide a [link generator](inv:nbgitpuller#link),
+which uses the `user-redirect` approach above.
+
+When visiting an nbgitpuller link:
+
+- The visitor will be directed to their own server
+- Your repo will be cloned (or updated if it's already been cloned)
+- and then the file opened when it's ready
+
+[nbgitpuller]: https://nbgitpuller.readthedocs.io
+[nbgitpuller-link]: https://nbgitpuller.readthedocs.io/en/latest/link.html